The Quiet Death of the AI Tools That Worked
Last night I was at CEDIA, the smart home trade conference. The conversation I want to write about happened on the exhibit floor. It ended with a tool I love announcing its own shutdown in my hand.
The Conversation
This booth caught my eye because i read homes and assumd they were building smart home from scratch..I was talking to Philippe Lafoucrière, Founder and CTO of Selora Homes, and Z. Michael Miranda, also at Selora. Selora is an AI-first smart home company built on Home Assistant. Philippe sold his previous company to GitLab in 2018. He is not a man who needs a pitch.
They were demoing their software to me. The whole demo was on a phone. Philippe and Michael kept tapping through screens. Features. Systems. Tedious settings.
Micheal even suggested Philipp show me the automated suggestions the app gives you.
I watched them looking down at the phone over and over.
The Realization
And I realized something while it was happening.
Every morning when I get ready, I put Huxe on. I do not touch my phone. The audio just plays. I move through my morning. I got down notes and blog post ideas.
Smart home software is supposed to free people from their devices. It is being demoed on the device. The whole industry is making people look at phones to control the things that are supposed to make them not need phones.
I told Philippe and Michael. Voice and audio, not screens. Their tech is the home. Huxe is the way you experience it without holding a phone. The integration would be real.
They asked How?
I explaind there is this app called Huxe. It's a brief app and i went to my phone to show them (ironically) and went to the app.
What Happened Next
I wanted to show them Huxe. The exhibit floor was loud. I opened the app, started a playback, and handed the phone to Michael so he could hear it.
He held it to his ear. He looked confused.
He told me he just heard the app was closing.
I took the phone back. I replayed it. I confirmed it for myself.
I was mortified.
The pitch I was making in that moment died on the table while I was making it. Three of us at CEDIA. The CTO of an AI-first smart home company, his commercial counterpart, and me. The shutdown announcement played in real time. The tool I was pointing to as the missing piece announced itself out of existence in the same breath.
The Pattern
Huxe was an AI-powered audio briefing app built by the team that originally built NotebookLM at Google. You told it what you cared about. It generated audio about it. You listened while you got ready in the morning. The phone stayed in your pocket.
Spotify shipped a similar personal-podcast feature the day before Huxe announced the shutdown. Adobe, Amazon, ElevenLabs, and Meta have all emulated the underlying capability. The consumer AI market commoditized the feature in under a year.
The official statement from the Huxe team was short. They chose to wind down. They are moving on to new things.
But they had options. A paid tier. A customizable version. A B2B pivot. Users like me would have paid serious money for the calibrated audio briefing.
They chose not to take them.
The Disconnect Argument
The conversation I was trying to start with Philippe and Michael was about voice-first interaction with a smart home. The reason the demo on the phone bothered me was that it modeled the wrong relationship between human and house. If your home is supposed to be smart, you should not need to look at a screen to talk to it. The interface should disappear.
Phones build disconnect. Not because phones are bad. Because every interaction with a phone is a moment where you are not in the room you are standing in. You are not present with the person next to you. You are not noticing the morning.
The tools worth fighting for are the ones that get out of your way. The ones that give you back the morning instead of taking it. The ones that make the phone unnecessary instead of central.
The Sharp Version
We lost a tool like that this week. Not because users did not want it. Because the team chose to stop instead of building the paid customizable version users would have paid for.
This is the pattern. Small builder makes something good. Big platform copies the feature. Small builder folds. The user — the person who actually integrated the product into a working day — has no vote in any of it. Not because we lack interest. Because no one builds the path.
The next builder who makes something I love this much, I am paying for. Even if it is free. Especially if it is free. Because what I want to keep is the option to keep it.
For Members
I wrote a longer version of this post for Mindful Dollar members on Buy Me a Coffee. It includes the part of the story I left out here — what Huxe actually did inside my mornings, why losing it is a real operational setback for the work I am building, and what I think the next builder needs to get right.
If this post resonated, the deeper version is where the real reflection lives.